7

Liturgical Worship or Concert Attendance?

Reflecting Upon Attending a Christian Concert

On Friday, February 4, I attended the Rock and Worship Roadshow at the Resch Center in Green Bay, WI.[i]  I went because the artist Matt Maher was playing and I hoped to have the opportunity to meet and talk with him.[ii]  I am glad to say that I was able to do so.

Just after Matt Maher played, the Resch Center got really quiet as the host for the evening took the stage and gave a push for donations to keep the costs for the concert down so others could attend and be blessed.  Maher came back out and started to play a soft song while buckets (literally) were passed around the Center to collect the donations.

Matt Maher with Kevin Symonds

While the buckets were passed around, I leaned over and said to a friend next to me, “This looks a lot like the collection plate [being passed around] at Mass.”

At some time during the performance of the heavy metal band “Thousand Foot Krutch.” I connected the environment of the concert with an all-too-familiar “boredom” that young people feel when they attend Mass.  This made me start to reflect about the Liturgy and contemporary culture with respect to music.

When I was teaching in Alabama, I discussed with my students some of the differences between Catholicism and Protestantism.  My otherwise Catholic students stated some contradictory facts, one of which was they sometimes attend Protestant services because — in the words of one female student — “they are more funner.”  She was referring to the upbeat style of music that endears young people [read: the rock-n-roll, “praise and worship” (so-called) genre of music]. 

At the concert, I began to appreciate on a deeper level that young people are “bored” at Mass because they aren’t “entertained.”  They go to a rock concert so as to be entertained.  Add to the fact that “Christian” rock concerts have a “worship” element, it is reasonable to state that some sort of connection is made between the music and worship.  I am concerned about how this is affecting people’s view of the Mass.  I have in my mind a concern for the practice of the art of contemplation, toward which is geared all Christian prayer.

Rock and Worship or Rock versus Worship

Contemplation necessarily requires silence because it is in silence that God speaks.  How is it possible to attain to this goal of Christian prayer when one pumps his or herself full of the busy-busy-busy, thrum-thrum-thrum that is the constant noise made by the so-called “praise & worship” music?

In my experience working with young people, I continuously hear, “You have to reach them where they are at.  This is the music they know and so we use it to reach them.”  Much can be said in favor of this statement and I understand the thought behind it.  However, I wish to point out that with respect to contemporary Christian music and the Liturgy, we might be defeating our efforts to evangelize and catechize young people so as to help them with understanding and conversion for insertion into the Mystery of Christ.

As a Christian society, we have our own culture, our own Tradition that has been established by Divine Authority.  We believe what is good in other cultures can be used for the sake of propagating the Gospel, but there is always a fine-line between what is sacred and what is profane.  By its very history, rock music falls into the category of profane.  Despite this, otherwise well-meaning Christians noticed the effect this style of music has upon people.  They have capitalized on it by taking the style, putting “Christian lyrics” into it and call it an “alternative” for Christians.

Remembering the distinction between the sacred and the profane, allow me to ask a question: With respect to music, are we perpetuating the secular culture that surrounds the genre of so-called “praise and worship” music or are we promoting an authentic Catholic culture? 

Sadly, I suspect that we are perpetuating secular culture.  I suspect this because of what I see of the way young people treat and/or think about the Liturgy.

By its very nature, the Liturgy is contemplative.  It requires contemplation so as to draw people deeper into the sacred mysteries.  This is a reciprocal relationship: contemplation for contemplation, the sacred mysteries and the soul.  What is necessary for this process is the disposition of soul called “quietude,” that is when our hearts rest in God.  The opposite of this resting is the “inquietude” made famous by St. Augustine in his famous quote from his Confessions, “For you made us for You and our hearts are restless until they rest in You.”

It is because of the contemplative nature of the Liturgy that any music composed for the Liturgy must necessarily conform to the spirit of the Liturgy.  The Catholic Church has upheld throughout the centuries Gregorian Chant (and Sacred Polyphony) as fulfilling this requirement and Pope Benedict XVI in his recent Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation, Verbum Domini, 70 (Latin text) desires the Church to retain the Chant.[iii]

These two beautiful pieces of our liturgical patrimony are intimately rooted in contemplation.  In order for young people to understand them, they need to have inculcated within themselves a proper docility and disposition towards the contemplative life/prayer.  In short: they need appropriate formation.  What would happen if young people are never given (or worse, denied) such formation by those who have proper care over souls: namely, parents, educators, priests/bishops and religious/seminary formators?

In a society that does not believe in much — if any — self-restraint/-discipline, this formation is hard to come by.  The necessary ascetism is fast becoming a lost art, even within the society of the Catholic Church.  I am reminded of the words of Pope Pius XI in his Encyclical Caritate Christi Compulsi (23, 25):

Certainly We know, and with you, Venerable Brethren, We deplore the fact that in our day the idea and the name of expiation and penance have with many lost in great part the power of rousing enthusiasm of heart and heroism of sacrifice….As a fact the notion of the need of penance and expiation is lost in proportion as belief in God is weakened, and the idea of an original sin and of a first rebellion of man against God becomes confused and disappears.

Penance then is, as it were, a salutary weapon placed in the hands of the valiant soldiers of Christ, who wish to fight for the defense and restoration of the moral order in the universe. It is a weapon that strikes right at the root of all evil, that is at the lust of material wealth and the wanton pleasures of life. By means of voluntary sacrifices, by means of practical and even painful acts of self-denial, by means of various works of penance, the noble-hearted Christian subdues the base passions that tend to make him violate the moral order.[iv]

Speaking about a musical genre — rock music — that, by its very nature, is highly expressive of the passions, the task of restraint is practically impossible. 

My challenge to all Christians is to remember that you are children of the Light.  The Eternal Father has given you a rich patrimony that has been passed down through your forefathers.  If the onslaught of secularism and relativism has reduced Western civilization to being a distant memory of its former glory, do not allow yourselves to run with the times.  Be faithful to the Tradition, persevere and grow strong in it. 

Do not conform yourselves to this age but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and pleasing and perfect” (Romans 12:2).


Kevin Symonds writes from South Carolina.  He received his B.A. and M.A. in Theology from Franciscan University of Steubenville and is the author of the book, Private Revelation: What Does the Catholic Church Teach?


Filed under: »
  • kmtierney

    Hello Kevin,

    I wrote a bit about this over at my blog. In short, I like it, but think you should drill deeper on this.

    Will shoot you an email giving a better understanding of what I mean.

    http://commonsensecatholicism.blogspot.com/2011/05/on-praise-and-worship-music-letter-to.html

    is where you can find my take on your essay.

  • nickkname

    There’s no rock music in Heaven. All the rock stars in Heaven do as the angels do. So should we in the Sacrament of the Eucharist, for it is a foretaste of Heaven.

  • noelfitz

    Reading this I am reminded of General Booth’s question “Why should the devil have all the best tunes?”.

    At Mass there is other music besides polyphony and Gregorian chant. Very many of the best composers have written music for Mass, including Beethoven, Mozart and Schubert.

    I believe at Mass we should have the best music possible, played and sung at the highest quality we can achieve.

    Also sermons should be prepared well and delivered well. The liturgy should be done as reverently and as well as possible. The church, flowers, vestments and behavior of ministers and congregations should reflect respect and high esteem for the Mass.

  • Thomas Colyandro, MA, MDiv

    Well stated, Kevin. Thank you for your thoughts on this subject as it is becoming increasingly important for the Church to recover a true udnerstanding of and need for contemplation.

  • christymomof3

    Yes, in a perfect church, we would all slip directly into contemplation as soon as we walk in the door, but we are not perfect, so we need help. In my view, based on scripture and personal experience, we would begin the Mass with praise songs (Psalm 100) and move into worship songs, leading us into contemplation. In my parish, though, we do a couple of verses of whatever strikes the fancy of the music leader. The midmorning Sunday Mass too often begins, continues, and ends either with social gospel songs or African-American spirituals, complete with clapping to the beat. Thank God the Eucharist is still the Body and Blood of Christ.

  • Deblette

    I agree with every single thing you said. I find most praise and worship music repetitive, shallow, protestant and self focused. I listen to it in my car and I like it but, I am so very weary of hearing it in my church.

  • MichaelGbell

    “Martyrs’ Prayers” is a recently released CD by the Catholic band The Project. You might find it interesting. Website: http://themartyrsproject.com